Amidst all political speculation, incumbents in this year's primary were supposedly geared for massive defeat, on both a local and national level. Yet in our own state incumbents won 30 of 58 seats (a number that's actually higher, albeit one seat, than 2006's primary outcome).
Now does this mean that the anti-incumbency feeling has subsided? Probably not, but that it was probably grossly overrated and that the citizens of Indiana are no longer as interested in party affiliation, but rather what you can, have and plan to do if elected.
In the race for the Republican seat in State District 22, (now former) Rep. Bill Ruppel was ousted by political newcomer Rebecca Kubacki in a tight, but decisive outcome, losing by 715 votes (8 percent). Instead of following the old adage of being humble in victory and gracious in defeat, Bill has decided to take the road less traveled, blaming his loss at the hands of the Indiana Chamber, the anti-incumbency movement, and being out spent "10 to 1."
Now while the Indiana Chamber's endorsement of Rebecca Kubacki was substantial, and while there may have been some feelings of anti-incumbency, it would be foolish to say these were the deciding factors. Perhaps her tireless efforts to knock door to door in order to personally introduce herself to constituents of the district earned her their support. Maybe it was the numerous events she hosted or spoke at that got people on board. Maybe it was her involvement in numerous (and I mean numerous) volunteer efforts in our community that earned her constituent support.
Could it be, Bill, that you were just out campaigned and outworked? Could it be that the Indiana Chamber looks at Rebecca as a candidate who best exemplifies the values and mission they want compared to you? Could it be that the constituents respected Rebecca's hard work, dedication and fresh ideas?
I think it's safe to say "yes" to all of the above, Bill, and ridiculous to assert this election was won by through a TV commercial or yard signs. Rather it was won through hard work, strong core values and a greater desire to listen to the community to make it a better place.
Now while Rebecca may be my mother, with my feelings/support biased, I do not think there is anyone who could debate that the above are not the reasons for outcome.
I think there's no better time than the present, Bill, to pick up the phone, congratulate your opponent on a job well done, and move on.
