College football is changing again. While change isn't always a good thing, I'm having a hard time getting too worked up about this one.
Let’s lay out the facts in case you haven’t read or heard about them earlier this week:
The expansion of the College Football Playoff (CFP) from 12 teams to 24 teams takes effect in the 2027 season punctuated by a (Monday) January 24 championship contest.
The Power 4 conferences (Big Ten, Big 12, SEC, ACC) announced they will discontinue their championships.
The first two rounds will feature 16 campus-hosted games.
The selection committee’s FCS-opponent policy is it will not give weight to wins overo more than one FCS opponent.
The Army-Navy game retains its protected weekend (December 4 in the 2027 season) with the Heisman Trophy event holding onto its real estate on the same Saturday as the Army-Navy game.
A 24-team College Football Playoff? More meaningful games in December? Thursday, Friday, and Saturday nights filled with college football? Bidding farewell to fewer conference championship games sometimes doing more harm than good?
Where do I sign up?
I realize there are plenty of traditionalists who believe we're messing with a good thing. They have legitimate arguments, and I'll get to a few of them. Before we start mourning the death of college football as we know it, though, maybe we should consider what we're gaining.
After all, isn't the idea to give more teams a legitimate opportunity to compete for a national championship while giving fans more meaningful football to watch?
Almost all the other college sports have a tournament far less parochial than college football’s legacy systems.
Here's where I land.
I'm willing to give the 24-team playoff a chance. I like the additional football, I like the opportunities it creates, and I like the possibility of a team outside the traditional powerhouse programs possibly making a serious run.
But I'm curious where you stand.
I'm leaning toward the positives, but I'm not ready to declare victory just yet.
What say you? Will this improve college football, or are we fixing something although it wasn't broken?
I'm eager to hear your thoughts.
There's another part of this discussion I find interesting: the transfer portal. This echoes a discussion in a previous column several weekends ago, but please indulge me, nonetheless.
When the pay-for-play era arrived, the conventional wisdom was the wealthiest programs would simply buy up all the best players. The rich would get richer, and everybody else would be left fighting for scraps.
This certainly happens. But there's another side to the story surfacing. Again, I already noted this a while ago.
What happens to the highly recruited player who signs with Alabama, Georgia, Ohio State or one of the other traditional powerhouses, only to discover he's third on the depth chart? Does he patiently wait for his opportunity? Maybe. But increasingly, those players are looking elsewhere.
They want playing time, to contribute to their program. Sometimes a player who might never get off the bench at a powerhouse can become a difference-maker at a school who needs him.
This doesn't mean the playing field is suddenly level. The biggest programs still have tremendous financial and recruiting advantages. Look at college football before NIL and pay to play.
College football was becoming regional, and much to my disappointment, too doggone Southern. The aforementioned changes were embraced by Big Ten schools and other large universities like Texas with huge alumni base, a superior wealth among these alumni bases contributing to their alma mater’s athletic department’s operating funds.
The transfer portal resulted in immediate national prominence for the Big Ten, and as the dust settles it’s creating opportunities for other programs to acquire talent otherwise remaining buried on somebody else's bench.
Could this help produce a few more surprises in a 24-team playoff? I wouldn't rule it out.
The removal of meaningless, medium talent (at best) December bowl games, and the reduction of risks associated with a conference championship game that feeds on itself are among the collective upside I see in the CFP expansion.
The planned five-season control group will be sufficient to shed light on how all the aforementioned merits hold up. In the meantime, you’ll get no complaints from me.