Looking back at last week’s column, it definitely ranks among my harshest ever, and while I apologize for nothing I said because I am right, I have been thinking about it a lot. It’s easy for someone to write the obituary, to kick something while it’s down. To look at something, say “it’s broken” and walk away. It takes a real man to step up and offer solutions.
And that’s exactly what I’m going to do today.
Yes, after spending so much time these past couple of years complaining about college football and the direction it is heading I’ve decided to put my money where my mouth is and figure out how we’re going to get out of this mess myself. So buckle up people, you have been transported to an alternate universe in which Times-Union sports editor Connor A. McCann, has been named supreme overlord of college football. (aka the commissioner but supreme overlord sounds so much cooler).
Now before I get into my first order of business, I’d like to explain that I am taking over college football today, as it currently stands. Yes, an easy way to fix it would be getting rid of the transfer portal and the NIL, but we can’t exactly put the toothpaste back in the tube. We are going to do our best at picking up the pieces as they are laid out in front of us. Starting with…
That pesky transfer portal. I can’t get rid of it, but there has to be a way to reel things in a bit. On day one as your commissioner, I’m implementing transfer limits. Simple enough: you are allowed to transfer one time with no penalty. Following that first transfer, you will be forced to sit out and lose a year of eligibility, no exceptions. I’m pretty surprised this isn’t a rule that’s in place already, but we’re going to take it a step further. No transfers within the same conference will be allowed.
Now, off the top that does sound harsh, but non-compete clauses exist in workplaces and fields all over the world already. We aren’t going to be giving these schools a salary cap or anything. Bigger schools are going to have more resources. That’s been a part of college sports far before NIL. Now, they can use those resources to scout the players they spend all year playing against only to poach them after the season is over. The rich only get richer while the smaller schools basically turn into developmental programs for the big dogs. Now, I know my rule doesn’t stop a kid from Arkansas from getting a big deal from Ohio State, but at least he’s not going to torture them playing at Georgia for the next three years.
While we’re on the topic of conferences, we might as well overhaul those while we’re here. I don’t know how we got to a point where the Big 10 and SEC both have 20 teams and run the sport by themselves, but I find that to be completely unacceptable. If you have so many teams in your conference that you can’t play every other one in a season, you have too many teams. Like I said earlier, you can’t really put the toothpaste back in the tube, and conference realignment is not going to be easy to reverse. However, as the commissioner, I can make my own rules, including introducing new conference bylaws that include both geographical limitations and a strict 10-team limit. Playing each team in your conference is crucial to my next rule, which we’ll get to in a second.
Let’s start by talking geography. To put it simply, a big reason college football is what it is is because of the pride fans have for their school, as well as the hatred of their rivals. What this sport has done to rivalries over the past decade is unfathomable. Half of them have to be played in the first three weeks of the season because the two teams don’t share a conference anymore. The other half don’t play at all or are missing the juice because the stakes are so much lower. The less that these rivalries and school pride matters, the more college football just becomes Diet NFL. Who needs to watch that when I can just tune into the real thing on Sundays? We will need to shuffle some things around, we may even need to introduce some new conferences, but there is no world where two of them should have 75% of the power. We need to make geography matter again, the fans will thank us for it.
Now those are two pretty big changes, and we haven’t even gotten to the playoff yet. You see, the very second I am sworn in as commissioner, I am not only firing every single member of the College Football Playoff Committee, I am doing so on national television so the world can see these buffoons get what they deserve. Do you know how hard it is to be unqualified to watch football? These people show you that they are each week when they announce their rankings. They're making it up as they go, and we are forced to just deal with whatever they decide.
No longer.
I have devised a new playoff system. One that doesn’t rely on anything except for the results on the field. I only ask that you keep an open mind as I say what I’m about to say. It may not be popular, but I wasn’t named the commissioner to make people happy. I’m here to save the sport.
As we dive deeper and deeper down the hole of NIL, the gap between the schools at the top of FBS football and teams at the bottom only continues to widen. I have been a longtime champion of the little guy. I think these smaller schools, no matter how big of underdogs they may be, deserve the chance to compete with the big boys. Most of the college football world does not see it that way, as Group of Six teams are only guaranteed one spot in both the 12 and 24-team playoffs.
So, unfortunately, to give those schools and those kids something to really play for, I propose a separation. This is where it gets complicated so stay with me. My proposal is to split the FBS down the middle. Once the Big 10 and SEC get rid of the schools needed to get down to 10 teams, and the other conferences follow, I’d like to see six power conferences. All of the other teams would then operate in a subdivision below, above FCS, but the same concept. Both the power conferences and the subdivision will have their own separate playoffs.
The power conferences will continue to have a 12-team playoff. I am the commissioner. ESPN does not own me, so I could care less about them not getting their 24 team expansion. However, there will be additional playoff games because as you remember, I fired the committee. The playoff field will be decided as follows: The top four teams in each of the six conferences will play. The No. 1 team against No. 4 and No. 2 against No. 3. The two winners will advance to the playoff. Six conferences, two spots each, don’t like it? Win your games. Seeding from there will have tiebreakers such as overall record, points scored and allowed, etc.
You quickly realize there is no spot left for Notre Dame. I know! Join a conference. Problem solved.
There is one more wrinkle I will add. We can’t separate these schools forever, as what if some of these smaller schools put in the work and resources and really build a program? To quote my childhood hero Anakin Skywalker “this is where the fun begins.”
At the end of each season, just as the teams at the top of the conferences are rewarded, teams at the bottom will be penalized. After the year wraps up, the two schools that finish 9th and 10th in their conferences will be demoted, while 12 of the subdivision schools are promoted in their place the following year. Think of the relegation system in soccer. The smaller schools have something else to play off besides a trophy, and it keeps the teams at the top competitive as they seek to avoid a demotion.
Now, there is so much more to go over, like what the subdivision’s playoff would look like, and limiting coaches from leaving schools in even worse fashion than their players, but I feel like this is a good start. If I can accomplish all of that on my first day, I think we’re looking at a pretty good tenure. Again, the real solution would be to travel back in time 20 years and prevent all of this from happening, but we have to work with what we have left. I hope you all enjoyed this exercise and if you have any ideas of your own on how to fix this sport, I’d love to hear them. My inbox is always open.
Commissioner Connor has rambled for long enough, it’s time for him to pick some games.
FAVORITE FAVORITE
Jacksonville Jaguars (-5.5) at New York Giants
This is one of those “keep it simple” picks for me. The Jaguars have been one of the best teams in the AFC this season, and have taken advantage of teams lower than them on the totem pole all year. The Giants are another one of those, and I just don’t think the G-Men will be able to keep up with Jacksonville and Trevor Lawrence offensively.
The Pick: Jaguars -5.5
BIG DAWG GOTTA EAT
Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Detroit Lions (-7)
This Buccaneer defense is playing lights out, and should be well rested after a bye. They’ll have a tough task in slowing down an extremely potent Lions offense, but Tampa did pretty well against the Bears a couple of weeks ago. Offensively, the visitors are going to struggle, especially if Baker Mayfield is unable to go with a foot injury. I think the defense keeps this close enough for the visitors to come up with a cover.
The Pick: Buccaneers +7
BEAR DOWN
New Orleans Saints at Chicago Bears (-11.5)
This is the first of two extremely lopsided spreads featuring our two local teams, and by now my hatred of these double-digit spreads is well documented. The Bears enjoyed a bye week last week after three straight wins in primetime, the final one being a close one against Tampa Bay in which Chicago somehow came away with a victory despite five turnovers and an overall poor performance. Hosting the Saints after a week off to get right and put that game behind them, not to mention needing as many wins as possible to keep up with a stacked NFC North, I think they get it done in a big way.
The Pick: Bears -11.5
THIS IS OUR COLTS
Indianapolis Colts at Houston Texans (-12.5)
Listen, the Colts are done. They aren’t playing for anything, they don’t have a first-round pick and they’ve traded almost everybody away. I don’t think they will win this game. However, I have not seen anything from the Texans this season that indicates to me that they should be nearly 13-point favorites over anyone. They’ve lost plenty of games they should have won and have barely squeaked by in a ton of their wins. Houston gets it done at home on Thursday night, but Indy is going to stick around.
The Pick: Colts +12.5
GAME OF THE WEEK
Minnesota Vikings at San Francisco 49ers (-3)
I told my good buddy Janas that I would give the Vikings a break from this spot this week after picking against them two weeks in a row. Turns out I vastly overestimated the rest of this week’s games, because this is absolutely the best contest on Sunday. I will not lie. Even with how good that defense has looked, I was not taking Minnesota too seriously because of their lack of offense. Kirk Cousins seemed to remedy that overnight, and I am now 100% looking at them as a Super Bowl contender. That being said, they are going up against a team that looks to be the very best in football so far this season. I’ve said it all week long and I’ll say it again: the NFC North is so good the only teams NFC North teams lose to are other NFC North teams. I’m shocking the world. I’m taking the risk. Give me the Vikings.
The Pick: Vikings +3
Wow, I don’t think I’m exaggerating when I say this is one of the worst slates I’ve ever had to pick. Good games look to be few and far between this weekend, enjoy what you can as we prepare for Thanksgiving.
Cheers.
P.S. If for some reason this is my last column of the year, it’s because I started playing Grand Theft Auto VI.
Last Week’s Record: 2-2
Season Record: 26-23