Editor, Times-Union:
I’ve spent weeks digging into the proposed Courts of Colfax development, reviewing the developer’s application to the state of Indiana, examining property records, working through the financial projections, and questioning Warsaw’s economic development director.
And I’ve reached a conclusion.
This is a bad deal for Warsaw, and the City Council should reject it.
Here’s why.
Courts of Colfax already exists. It has 78 apartments for seniors. The developer wants to renovate those apartments, and I’m all for it. Our seniors deserve safe, affordable housing.
But take a look at the numbers.
According to the developer’s own state application, this is a $13.4 million deal.
Of that, $6.12 million goes toward purchasing a property the organizations involved already control. Another $1.85 million is set aside for developer fees.
And here’s my favorite part. Nearly $3.56 million of that property purchase is financed through a loan between the connected organizations.
Zero percent interest. Zero dollars in scheduled annual payments. A 15-year loan term.
Meanwhile, the project is seeking approximately $5.7 million in federal housing tax credits, which are expected to attract roughly $4.8 million from private investors.
Maybe this is perfectly normal in the world of affordable housing development. Maybe moving millions of dollars between related organizations and collecting substantial developer fees is just how these deals work.
But just because something is legal or common doesn’t mean Warsaw taxpayers should subsidize it.
After putting together all that financing, the developer wants our City Council to approve a special property tax arrangement for 20 years.
And what exactly does Warsaw get?
About $23,000 the first year, increasing 3% annually, deposited into a special city fund for affordable housing instead of being distributed through our normal property tax system.
The city argues this arrangement could eventually bring in more money than regular property taxes. I’ve examined that explanation, too, and I’m not convinced.
We’re not getting 78 new apartments. Those apartments already exist. We’re not adding a single new housing unit or expanding the city’s housing capacity.
We’re renovating an existing building.
That’s a worthwhile investment, but the renovations benefit the property and its residents whether or not the city calls this economic development.
When we give a company a tax break to build a factory and hire 500 people, there’s an obvious return to the community. Jobs, economic activity, and new investment that wouldn’t otherwise exist.
Where is that return in this deal?
I’ve read the numbers. I’ve challenged the explanations. I’ve done the homework. And I have not seen a convincing financial case that this project needs another 20 years of favorable property tax treatment.
The developer stands to collect substantial fees and secure millions in financing. Warsaw gets an agreement that redirects property tax payments into a restricted account while adding no new housing.
That’s not a trade I’m willing to support.
I support affordable housing. I support our seniors. I support renovating aging buildings.
But supporting those things doesn’t require approving every financial arrangement a developer puts in front of us.
The City Council has a responsibility to the people paying the bills, not just the people asking for the breaks.
Reject the Courts of Colfax PILOT.
Chris Plack
Warsaw, via email