Eagle with Stars and Stripes
Continuously serving Kosciusko County since 1854

City Council Approves PILOT Agreement For Courts Of Colfax With 5-2 Vote

Posted

Many numbers were thrown out during the Warsaw Common Council’s third night of discussion Monday about the Payment In Lieu Of Taxes (PILOT) agreement for Courts of Colfax, but it all came down to two digits.
Five council members voted for the motion to approve the agreement and two opposed.
In favor were President Jack Wilhite, Cindy Dobbins, Jerry Frush, Mike Klondaris and Diane Quance. Opposed were Juergen Voss and Josh Finch.
Two meetings ago, the PILOT program was first introduced to the council by Warsaw Community and Economic Development Director Jeremy Skinner and House Investments LLP CEO Matt Gadus as the city had never been presented with it before. Then at the Nov. 2 council meeting, there was more discussion from Skinner and Gadus, as well as council members and the public.
“The intent of the PILOT agreement is to give an incentive to affordable housing like we’ve done on a lot of other projects. In this case, this one is affordable senior housing,” Skinner said in reintroducing the agreement Monday. “Like I said before, this is not any different than a lot of the affordable housing projects we’ve incentivized, whether it be on the senior or on the family side. The main difference here is switching to a PILOT agreement from what would be historically the tax abatements we’ve given.”
One of the goals of the community is to increase housing opportunities, and this is just another one of those projects to continue to do that, he said. “In this case, we are restarting or rehashing this affordable housing project because it has expired, which basically means that they could, if they don’t re-up it to an affordable which you have before you with this PILOT agreement, it could go to market rate.”
The main difference between a PILOT and a tax abatement, Skinner reminded the council, is the PILOT agreement sets aside funds specific to affordable housing, as allowed by state statute that created the PILOT program. “This specific request is for 20 years and has a specific payment to schedule, and that schedule increases 3% every year for the next 20 years,” he stated.
Gadus, who was joined Monday by Partnerships for Affordable Housing (PAH) Executive Director Amy Burmeister, said the goal was to preserve 78 affordable housing units in Warsaw.
“The market data shows why that matters. The market survey that was recently completed last week ... 98% of the affordable housing units in Warsaw are currently occupied. If you take out Courts of Colfax, so if you take out those 78 units, you have 473 units left that are identified as affordable housing. Almost 99% of those are occupied. There’s a total of six vacant units, so the need for affordable housing is great. If you have occupancy that high in the market, you know there’s actually an additional need for housing, and to make sure you preserve what’s currently in place,” Gadus stated.
“The housing already exists. The need already exists, and our objective is to preserve it to make sure that at least 78 units are here for another 40 years,” he continued.
Burmeister said PAH is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit and their mission is to solely provide housing and offer wraparound services.
“I know there’s been a lot of chatter about income and expenses and debt and what have you, but as Matt said, the point is that we want to preserve these units. We want to stay in Warsaw. We love our residents. Warsaw’s been a great partner for us, but the asset is 33 years old. It needs some love. We’ve maintained the affordability over the last three years, although we didn’t have to. We could have raised it to market. We didn’t do that because it’s not within our mission to provide affordable housing, so we want to continue to do that for another 40 years ,” she said.
Under the low-income housing tax credit guidelines, Burmeister said they also could have done a 30-year commitment, but they chose a 40-year commitment because it falls within their mission.
Gadus, responding to questions from the Nov. 2 meeting, said a big component to get the deal to work is PAH rolling their equity into it. “So they’ve owned the asset for 33 years. It has appreciated in value because of inflation, because of time, value, money. They are rolling that equity into the new project. Not expecting a return. It’s sitting below, it’s behind permanent debt, behind IHCDA debt, it’s third in line. They’re rolling that in because they’re putting their money where their mouth is for their mission,” he said.
Burmeister said she thinks the question from the last meeting was why was PAH giving the loan to themselves. “We’re not. PAH is loaning its own equity to the property. We’re not loaning ourselves money, and as Matt said, we’re way down the capital stack,” she said. “A for-profit owner would have sold this deal and profited their equity, and that’s not our mission, that’s not what we want to do. We want to be here.”
Gradus said a lot has changed since the application with IHCDA for the tax credits, listing a number of things including the increase in operating expenses. He noted Lake City Bank is part of the investment group on the tax credits and the lender side. “This deal does not work without the PILOT,” he stated.
Voss, a landlord and realtor who has publicly expressed his opposition to the PILOT since the Nov. 2 meeting, said he’s taken 100 calls on the PILOT agreement for Courts of Colfax and compiled a list of questions he said the callers wanted to know, the first being who owned Courts of Colfax.
“We own Courts of Colfax, Partners for Affordable Housing,” Burmeister responded. Asked who will own Courts of Colfax “once this all over,” she said PAH will be the controlling member.
Gadus said the total project cost, all in, is around $14 million. “It’s financed through permanent debt through Lake City, IHCDA loan, seller rolling their equity into that, differed developer fee,” he responded to another question from Voss. Gadus also told Voss that the remodeling will include everything.
“What will be different if we don’t pass PILOT?” Voss asked.
“If you don’t pass the PILOT, there’s no affordable commitment for 40 years,” Gadus said.
“So it would probably just go to market rate?” Voss asked.
“We would have to discuss it as a board,” Burmeister said.
There were also questions about maintenance, personnel, the roof, relocation, cash flow, property taxes and a number of other things before Voss stated, “So I say to my fellow city councilmen, can you in good conscience say that you are going to vote to represent the will of your constituents and your fellow property taxpayers, and for that reason I am going to vote against it.”
A little later, Councilwoman Cindy Dobbins said that while she didn’t talk to as many people as Voss said he did, “I have stopped by there and I have talked to some of the residents and mostly very positive response about wanting to have the apartments redone. Is there a little squeamishness about the transition? Of course, and I would probably be a little squeamish myself about that.”
She said when she took a little look around Monday, the common areas do need a lot of updating and some of the residents she talked to were excited about the fact that it was going to be updated.
A few people contacted her, some negative, but mostly they just wanted to understand what the PILOT was about.
Quance said she was able to talk to some school officials on Monday. “They would much rather that we approve this tonight and start provide affordable housing than if they get any tax revenue because your estimate at what they lost at Harrison (Elementary School) was way low. They said it was at least 70 students and they said now that school is in trouble, populationwise, as far as usage of the building.”
Skinner said one of the family-affordable housing development projects he’s working on targets Harrison and they’re going to ask for a PILOT.
“And that is what they would much rather that we do because we need students back in Warsaw, instead of corporations to the north of us, so that we can continue to provide the educational quality that we do for our students,” Quance said, adding “we are helping the schools more by getting a fund so that we can offer something to people who want to build family-affordable housing.”
When Mayor Jeff Grose opened the meeting up to the public to talk about the PILOT, most of the speakers talked about the condition of the building, its upkeep and/or lack of upkeep. One person attributed Courts of Colfax needing the PILOT because of poor financial management, adding that government should not give handouts to businesses.
After public comments were closed, Wilhite said, “A lot of what we heard from the community tonight has been complaints about operations, and I’d like to remind the board here, the council, that we can’t do anything about the operations. Not really. This is about the PILOT program and whether or not we’re going to go PILOT or abatement, or even if we can go abatement.”
Wilhite looked up the taxes - which is available online - that Courts of Colfax paid over the last eight years. “And, things came to light to me that really made a whole lot of sense as to why this PILOT program is being submitted,” he said.
In 2017, they paid $18,294.49; 2018, up by $189; 2019, down $33; 2020, down $1,425; 2021, down $8.39; 2022, up $996.68; 2023, down $1,509.92; 2024, up $4,483. 34.
“I can see why banks will loan on a PILOT program that is stable. I don’t know what better rate you’re getting, but I’m sure you’re getting a better rate from the bank than you would if you were under taxes,” Wilhite stated. “Probably so good that you’re willing to pay a little bit more to us to get that low rate.”
The total taxes Courts of Colfax paid from 2017 to 2024 was $144,771.92. If the city had been able to do the PILOT program with Courts of Colfax starting in 2017 at an increase of 3% annually, the city would have $162,680. By going with an abatement instead of PILOT, the city would have foregone almost $18,000, he said.
“The PILOT program would actually bring more money into the city in revenue than doing it under the existing system,” Wilhite said. “... I don’t see how throwing away a PILOT program is going to benefit anybody.”